[정보/강좌]DPREVIEW:소니 비압축 RAW는 어떤 차이를 보여주나?
페이지 정보
9,641 2015.09.23 22:06
짧은주소
-
Short URL : https://slr4u.hoxy.io/bbs/?t=2Iy 주소복사
본문
출처 http://www.dpreview.com/articles/6144418951/what-difference-does-it-make-sony-uncompressed-raw
Sony has just announced that its latest cameras will gain the option to shoot uncompressed Raw files. The move comes in response to user feedback (and, we're told, our efforts to communicate this feedback to the company's senior management), and provides a choice between shooting the with the existing two-stage lossy compression or an uncompressed Raw file. Given the interest that was generated when we detailed the effects of Raw compression, we thought it was equally important to make clear the benefits of the newly-added uncompressed Raw option.
What difference does this make?
When we explained the impact of Sony's compression on Raw files, we said the localized second stage of the compression was the aspect that was most visually destructive and, sure enough, this is where the benefit to shooting uncompressed Raw is seen.
The removal of the localized compression of 16-pixel blocks means the files no longer introduce errors and artefacts around high-contrast edges.
![]() |
![]() |
And it's gone: the artefacts present in the compressed Raw file are completely absent in the newly uncompressed files. |
We've analysed the uncompressed Raw files and can't find a significant difference in the amount of dynamic range being offered. There's possibly a tiny improvement if you try to brighten very deep shadows but the difference is so subtle that we don't consider it to be photographically significant. But, even without this, the camera's Raw files are more flexible than they were before.
How big are the files?
They're essentially twice the size. The uncompressed Raw files we've shot are consistently around 81.4MB, compared to the ~40.7MB files produced of the same scene using compressed Raw.
What's the effect on continuous shooting?
This is where things become a bit unclear because we aren't able to test continuous shooting. We're told that uncompressed mode doesn't reduce the continuous shooting speed, it just reduces the number of shots that can be taken before the buffer fills.
Are they 14-bit?
![]() |
![]() |
Close examination using RawDigger shows that the uncompressed files no longer skip ever alternate Raw value: they're true 14-bit files, rather than having 13-bits of data in a 14-bit space. |
They certainly appear to be. We used RawDigger to examine the uncompressed files and found that there aren't large numbers of un-used Raw values as was the case before. However, until we can install final firmware on a production camera, we can't test continuous shooting so don't know what the files produced when the camera drops to 12-bit read-out mode will look like.
This is not the end of the story
In our discussions with Sony, the company was keen to stress that it is still listening. We suspect the reason Sony is offering uncompressed Raw, rather than losslessly-compressed Raw that some users would like, stems from the limitations of working with the cameras' existing processors, rather than any misunderstanding about consumer demands. The company says it will continue to listen and will investigate the development of a lossless compression system if there's sufficient user demand.
And, now that we've got access to uncompressed Raw files, we should be able to publish an assessment of image quality, early next week.
제대로 되는 모양입니다.진즉 말듣지.무손실 압축 RAW도 소비자가 강력하게 원하면 해주겠다?좀 알아서 해주지 마지못해 해주는 뉘앙스.
글쓴이 명함
nepo 회원등급 : 최고관리자 포인트 : 301,049
Progress Bar 59%
-
비 내리는 5월 16일
.
nepo 2025-05-16 22:30 10 -
2024 후반 서울 첫눈-관악구
.
nepo 2024-11-27 21:45 78 -
관악산
.
nepo 2024-09-22 17:47 82 -
63빌딩의 저녁
.
nepo 2024-09-15 19:33 86 -
하늘 달 구름 산 그리고 건물
.
nepo 2024-09-14 18:56 82 -
아카시 향기 속 관악 야경
.
nepo 2024-05-04 22:14 79 -
아카시 꽃
해마다 보는 아카시 꽃
nepo 2024-05-03 10:42 74 -
비온 후의 신록
.
nepo 2024-04-24 12:12 77 -
가까이 그리고 멀리서 본 북한산
.
nepo 2024-03-26 20:28 83 -
백운대 눈꽃
.
nepo 2024-02-24 02:04 90
-
귀엽습니다~ nepo 2022-12-07 00:12
-
곰팡이색이 검은색이 아니고 흰색이라 곰팡이만 걷어내고 먹으면 된다고 합니다. 냉장 보관하시… 안알랴줌 2022-08-19 18:21
-
너무 방치히는거 아닌가요? ? 도메인이 만료되기 전에 연장하라는 메일이 갈텐데? 안알랴줌 2022-06-28 17:03
-
점점 고물이 되어가는 모든것과 함께 아직은 즐거운 마음으로 삽니다 ㅎㅎ † ЌûỲắـĶĬΣ 2022-06-26 07:04
-
오오! Kuyakim님 오랜만입니다! 먼 타지에서 건강히 잘 지내시는지요 :) 풀림 2022-06-25 23:21
-
그런 카페가 한두곳이 아니죠 쓴소린 듣기 싫고 그런~ † ЌûỲắـĶĬΣ 2022-06-22 10:08
-
수고 많았네요^^ nepo 2022-06-22 00:29
-
허헛. 오랜만에 접속해보니 도메인이 죽어있어서 부랴부랴 살렸습니다. nepo님께 따로 연락… 풀림 2022-06-21 23:31
-
에구 너무 속상하시겠어요...ㅠㅠ 풀림 2022-06-21 23:30
-
제가 수정했습니다^^ nepo 2022-01-06 00:56
Ranking
-
01 안알랴줌241,207
-
02 † ЌûỲắـĶĬΣ214,573
-
03 봉자아범200,485
-
04 한댜139,334
-
05 고슴도치132,659
-
06 날좋은날예쁘게108,482
-
07 viva103,258
-
08 물빛102,791
-
09 돌팔매76,544
-
10 fomosan45,265
-
01 † ЌûỲắـĶĬΣ56,396
-
02 안알랴줌38,589
-
03 한댜38,235
-
04 고슴도치35,039
-
05 물빛28,982
-
06 돌팔매27,560
-
07 봉자아범20,346
-
08 fomosan18,529
-
09 강달프17,013
-
10 오키드15,321
댓글목록
한댜님의 댓글
아몰랑... 해석을 하려니 실력이 딸리고... 소니는 안 쓰고 캐논만 쓰고... ㅋㅋㅋ
1등 3P
freshsoul님의 댓글
http://www.popco.co.kr/zboard/zboard.php?id=dica_forum_sony&page=1&sn1=&divpage=8&category=5&sn=off&ss=on&sc=off&select_arrange=headnum&desc=asc&no=40338
해석입니다. DR에선 역시 별 차이가 없나보군요. 디테일 부분에서도 얼마나 좋아졌을지 의문이긴 하지만 이전 손실 압축 로우도 못 쓰겠단 생각은 해본 적이 없는지라...
암튼 소니가 예전과는 확실히 다른 모습을 보여주고 있단 점에서 반갑네요. 장노출 암부 크로마 노이즈 같은것도 바로 펌업으로 잡아줬고 14비트 무손실 로우까지 지원되니 현재로서 a7rii 바디 자체의 큰 단점은 없는 것 같습니다. 무게가 늘어난게 살짝 걸리긴 하지만 머 5축 손떨방 때문에 어쩔 수 없는 것 같기도 하고 저도 조만간 넘어가고 싶네요.
소니/미놀타 포럼 카테고리
소니/미놀타 포럼 검색
월간베스트